Minerva's Restaurant Review

The downtown area of Sioux Falls seems to have it all: diners, specialty stores, apartments, bars, and Falls Park. Nestled in the heart of it all is Minerva's Restaurant. So I invited two friends, Ryan and Christine, out for dinner. After living in Sioux Falls for over three years and hearing great stories about it, I went to try it for myself. After all, they say seeing is believing.

The first thing you encounter in any establishment, whether you acknowledge it or not is the atmosphere. It was dark, alluring, but also inviting. After our brisk walk in the 40 degree weather, I was relieved to step inside somewhere more comforting. Minerva's has a rustic feel to it that has aged with time and experience since its establishment in 1977.

Reservations are recommended, but because we chose a Tuesday evening, we were able to walk in and be seated immediately. Right away we were greeted with waters and had a few moments to settle in and become acquainted with drink and food menus. When we were ready, Christine and I ordered a bottle of Smoking Loon Pinot Noir ($24) to share and Ryan ordered a classic Crown Royal and Coke ($5.50).

Our server, Katie, had formal skills that could impress even the rudest guest. Not only did she do a great job of presenting and pouring the wine, but overall she is a well-rounded server. She was able to describe, in full detail, the Seafood Mac & Cheese and Crab and Potato Crusted Salmon. She also recommended her favorite of the two and was neither pushy nor impatient.

After much debate, I settled on the Seafood Mac & Cheese along with the salad bar ($19.95). Shortly after we placed our order, our server brought out a mix of white and wheat sliced baguettes accompanied with chilled butter.

The salad bar was fresh and offered a variety of salad toppings, cheeses, and soups. One downside was the limited choice of greens. The iceberg mix sufficed but I was, however, glad to see a salad bar attendant behind me keeping the lettuce bright and stocked. The salad bar, even a meal by itself ($10.95), offered items such as pickled herring, potato and Waldorf salads, and two varieties of soups. An item that makes this Sioux Falls salad bar unique was the fresh cheese blocks accompanied with your choice of crackers or mini bagels. These cheeses paired with the rich aroma of our Pinot Noir had me craving more as we chatted and drank together.

Unlike a typical casual dining restaurant, we were able to enjoy our time and conversation together over drinks and a light salad before our main entrees arrived. In a jeans and tshirt establishment (Applebees, Chili's, TGIFridays, etc.) the atmosphere is rushed and according to the clock, convenient. There, the goal is to pull in and push out as many people as possible in a limited amount of time. At Minerva's, from the time we ordered to the time we got our food was approximately a half hour. At any casual dining restaurant the food would more than likely be free if the ticket time ran that long. But in fine dining, time is set aside when good company, service, and drinks come together. The pace of our evening was outstanding and seamless.

When our entrees arrived, the plating was tidy and everything came out looking delicious. Ryan and Christine's steaks were done just as they had asked and liked. My mac & cheese kept its heat until the last bite. The cavatappi noodles were thoroughly cooked without sticking together and were tossed in a white Tillamook cream sauce. The hearty shrimp, salmon, and diced scallops reminded me of digging for treasure. Not that the pieces of seafood were scarce, because there was plenty, but because each piece of fish I found delighted me. The dish was neither too salty nor had the overbearing distinction of shellfish.

Dessert was a delightfully large portion (enough for all three of us to share) of Tiramisu ($5.50). The sweet chocolate was just the right touch to battle the strong Kahlua coffee base. Both sauces were layered beautifully over the soaked sponge cake creating a sweet ending to a great night.

Overall, Minerva's is an excellent place to treat yourself to a relaxed friendly environment. Well, that is if you can get there. Parking is limited on Phillips Avenue. However, the chase to downtown and trolling for a space is worth it. As an added bonus, you'll get to enjoy all the other businesses on the way: art galleries, bookstores, and clothing stores. Also, because Minerva's is a fine dining restaurant, children will most likely be left at home or with a sitter. In the restaurant I worked in, screaming children, high chairs, and an explosion of food was the norm. But at Minerva's, all that was heard was the soft jazz music and the mumble and laughter of other guests.

Minerva's Restaurant is a great establishment that can accommodate parties as large at 60 in their private room downstairs or as small as two people. They not only met my expectations but also surpassed them. My first experience left me feeling not only satisfyingly full, but also eager for a return visit. Turns out all the gossip was right because I am now a believer.



Minerva's Restaurant
301 S Phillips Ave.
Sioux Falls, South Dakota 57104
(605) 334.0386

Hours:
Serving in the Dining Room
Lunch 11:00 - 2:30
Dinner M-F 5:00 - 10:00
Sat 5:00 - 11:00

Limited menu available at the bar
from 2:30 pm until 5:00 pm